What is this string of bright green eggs? – Part 3

This is part three in a three-part series about photos of bright green eggs first submitted to AskaNaturalist.com in the summer of 2014. The photos came from a reader in Nova Scotia and another in Maine. To read part 1, click here. To read part 2, click here.

string of green eggs and tape measure
Nova Scotia “string of bright green eggs”
egg string - maine - 800
Maine “jelly blob”

Previously on “string of bright green eggs”: Two independently submitted strings of bright green eggs or something like eggs, from Nova Scotia and Maine, July-Aug 2014. In Part I, we considered amphibian eggs, algae and snails. In Part II, we rejected all those possibilities and came around to chironomids – insects known as “non-biting midges.” Some chironomid species lay their eggs in water in gelatinous, spirally organized egg mass strings that look similar to the Nova Scotia and Maine eggs. There was a nagging problem, however, in that in two cases where someone hatched out one of these egg masses, the hatchlings had six legs, whereas the larvae of chironomids are legless.

Still we decided chironomids was the best answer … but wait ….

Chironomid larvae with legs?: There are strong similarities between these egg masses and those of some chironomids, as the photo at the GoldFish Garage site shows (covered in part 2, click here to go to Goldfish Garage). But the photos Nancy from Maine had taken of her hatchlings clearly showed six legs – and chironomid larvae don’t have legs. That incongruity made me hesitant to declare victory and write up the chironomid answer. So I kept stalling …

Then, just when I finally decided I had to write it up and move on, I got a message from Charley Eiseman, who contributes to BugGuide.net and who has his own insect-related blog called Bug Tracks. Charley is a naturalist and author who co-wrote Tracks & Sign of Insects and Other Invertebrates. His book is on my Christmas wish list and I’ll do a review of it once I have it in hand. It sounds uniquely useful.

Charley responded to a photo I had placed on BugGuide.net weeks before that showed the egg mass and the hatchlings and asked for confirmation that the egg mass was chironomid. Charley’s response to my photo post said, “Well, as far as I know, donut-shaped egg masses are unique to caddisflies in the genus Phryganea. Also, chironomids, like most flies, have elongate eggs, whereas these are spherical, which is typical of caddisflies.”

I read this with great excitement because Charley’s identification would explain the six-legged hatchlings.

Adult Phryganea caddisfly
Adult Phryganea caddisfly

Caddisflies are insects that share with chironomids the trait of having their larvae develop in bodies of fresh water. Although the larvae of some of the approximately 12,000 caddisfly species are predatory, most caddisfly larvae feed on detritus, plant material, and algae. The Caddisfly order (Trichoptera) is related to the order that includes moths and butterflies (Lepidoptera), and you can see that resemblance in moth-like adult caddisflies and also in the fact that the juveniles go through a pupal stage the way that moths and butterflies do. In the case of caddisflies, the pupa is formed underwater, and the adult crawls out, floats to the surface and flies away. After the adults mate in the summer, they lay their eggs in the water. And some caddisflies in the genera Phryganea and Agrypnia lay strings of gelatinous, spirally organized egg masses that are characteristically looped or donut-shaped.

And the larvae, when they hatch, have six legs!

Phryganea caddisfly larvae
Phryganea caddisfly larvae

The larvae of most species build a long thin house by using silk to attach plant material, sand and other objects together. The larva crawls inside and wears the house pretty much round the clock nonstop until it is ready to pupate. The fact that they are very uncomfortable out of their house is shown in this somewhat humorous video of two caddisfly larvae competing for the same house: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-9Lu9f5tEE. You can read my previous article about caddisflies by clicking here.

To make what has been a long story a little bit shorter, after checking with a couple of caddisfly experts and looking at illustrations of caddisfly egg masses that seem very similar to those of the egg masses from Nova Scotia and Maine (as well as the ones I came across from Vermont and Montreal), I am prepared to say that Charley’s diagnosis of caddisfly eggs best fits all the evidence.

One key piece of evidence is that, as Charley said in his BugGuide.net response, chironomid eggs are nearly always elongated or oval shaped. Caddisfly eggs, on the other hand, are nearly always spherical. And now, if we go back to the eggs from GoldFish Garage, and zoom in, you’ll see they are elongated.

egg masses from Nova Scotia and Maine

The eggs in our Nova Scotia and Maine egg masses, on the other hand, are spherical, as shown in this zoomed in photo.

Maine’s list of caddisflies includes several species in the genus Agrypnia and Phryganea, as does Nova Scotia’s. We don’t know for sure the two egg masses came from the same species, of course. The egg masses of such closely related species probably look very similar.

But having confirmed that there are Agrypnia and Phryganea species in Maine and Nova Scotia, I am finally, at long last, confident in saying that the egg masses submitted by Emily in Nova Scotia and Nancy in Maine (as well as the eggs from Vermont on Robyn’s Pond Page) are almost certainly caddisfly eggs.

Phew! This was a fun one for me, but I apologize to Emily and Nancy, who had to wait so long for an answer.

Tying up loose ends:

Snails – “But what about the snails?” you might ask. Remember that the person who found the similar egg mass in Montreal insists that baby snails hatched from it. As we’ve seen, two not very closely related insect groups have evolved very similar egg masses, so it’s not out of the realm of possibility that a group of snails have also evolved a similar egg mass, as Rob Dillon discusses in his blog posts about this same subject. As far as I can tell, there are no snails known to lay this kind of egg mass, however, so I’m inclined to suggest that the baby snails were hitchhikers. I feel a tad hypocritical in saying this, because when the same kind of explanation was offered for the presence of six-legged larvae coming from an egg mass that was supposed to be chironomids (the larvae of which don’t have legs), I strongly disagreed. But I have only a third-hand connection to the person who had snail hatchlings, so I’m more willing to discount that observation. I don’t know where the snails came from, but I don’t think it was from the egg masses.

Size of egg masses – One of the reasons it was hard to accept chironomids as the layers of these egg masses is the size of the egg masses compared to adult midges. As the ruler included by Emily in her photo of the egg mass from Nova Scotia, these egg masses are more than two inches (5 cm) long. Although a few of the larger chironomid species can be 10 mm (3/8 inch), most are smaller than that. It was hard to imagine how a female chironomid adult could lay something so much larger than itself. Agrypnia and Phryganea caddisflies are considerably larger, up to 25 mm (1 in.) in length, but still the egg masses are considerably larger than the caddisfly female who lays it. It turns out that in both the chironomids and the caddisflies, the eggs are laid with only a sort of chemical latticework, which begins to swell as soon as it hits water, forming the tough gel that protects the eggs.

Academic opportunity – I lost track of how many people told me, “Hardly anyone studies the eggs.” Or “Very little is known about the eggs.” I heard this about freshwater snails, about chironomids and about caddisflies. If there’s a young biologist out there who is looking for an area in which to add to our knowledge of nature, this would be an easy area in which to make a permanent mark. I’m planning to look for egg masses myself next summer and hatch some out. I’ll keep you posted.

That striking green color – One other mystery remains. Why are some of these eggs so green? In nature, that bright green color is almost always a sign of chlorophyll. In some species of amphibians, the eggs have a symbiotic relationship with algae. The microscopic algae benefit by living in the protection of the egg mass gel. The eggs benefit because the algae release oxygen, something that is critical to eggs that are stuck in the deep middle of an egg mass. Oxygen diffuses through the mass from the water, but if you can get a little extra from some symbiotic algae, it’s a bonus.

So is that what’s happening with these bright green caddisfly eggs? Are they symbiotic with algae? And the green chironomid eggs as well? And why were Nancy’s eggs green the first time she saw them and more brown the second time. As far as I can tell, no one has studied this. Another opportunity for a biologist to take up.

Two mysteries with one answer – When Charley Eiseman was poking around on AskaNaturalist.com, he came across another article I wrote: “Donut blob that stumped the experts ….” This was about a gelatinous donut-shaped object a reader found in a Maine lake. Charley offered the possibility that the translucent donut might be what’s left of a caddisfly egg mass once the larvae have hatched and crawled away to build their little houses. This is by far the most reasonable explanation I’ve heard for this donut blob and I’m inclined to think that Charley has solved that mystery as well. Caddisflies are everywhere!

caddisfly eggs - 2015
Hanna’s green eggs

Another One – Summer 2015:  A reader sent this message and photo in August, 2015.  “While kayaking in a fresh water lake in Northern Idaho I pulled a stick out of the water and found this exact same thing.”  Hanna.

Hanna’s photo really captures the beauty of these things!

Thank yous: Thank you to Rob Dillon for all his help and his interest in this case, which helped keep me pushing for a good answer. Thanks also to Charley Eiseman for the answer to the mystery, Alexander Huryn, aquatic ecologist at the University of Alabama, who also suggested caddisflies, and to caddisfly experts John Morse at Clemson University, David Houghton at Hillsdale College and Ralph Holzenthal at the University of Minnesota for help in providing evidence that supports the Phryganea/Agrypnia caddisfly answer. I also greatly appreciate help with chironomids from Professor Ali Arshad at the University of Florida, independent chironomid expert John Epler, David at GoldFish Garage, Bohdan Bilyj, and Jon Martin at the University of Melbourne.

Thank you also, to Robyn Rhudy at FishPondInfo.com and J. Trevor Vennata, who studies snails at the University of Minnesota.


http://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1163&context=aes_techbulletin, The Caddisflies (Trichoptera) of Maine, Excepting the Family Hydroptilidae, R. L. Blickle and W. J. Morse, Bulletin T-24 November 1966.

Wiggins, G. (1998). The caddisfly family Phryganeidae (Trichoptera). Toronto: Published in association with NRC Research Press, Canada Institute for Scientific and Technical Information by University of Toronto Press.

Rasmussen, A.K., & Morse, J.C. 2014. Distributional Checklist of Nearctic Trichoptera (Summer 2014 Revision). Unpublished, Florida A&M University, Tallahassee. 487 pp.  [Available at http://www.Trichoptera.org]

Hinton, H.E. 1981. Biology of Insect Eggs. 3 volumes. Pergamon Press, Oxford.

Hickin, N. (1968). Caddis larvae; larvae of the British Trichoptera. Rutherford [N.J.: Fairleigh Dickinson University Press.

Frost, S. (1959). Insect life and insect natural history (2d rev. ed.). New York: Dover Publications.

Cite this article as: Pelletier, TC. (December 19, 2014). What is this string of bright green eggs? – Part 3 Retrieved from http://askanaturalist.com/what-is-this-bright-green-string-of-eggs-part-3/ on July 3, 2020.

11 thoughts on “What is this string of bright green eggs? – Part 3”

  1. Today (August 11th, 2015) while kayaking in a fresh water lake in Northern Idaho I pulled a stick out of the water and found this exact same thing out of the water and since then I have been researching what it could be. I would love to also share with you my photos that I have taken. I am very curious!!

  2. Hi Tom!!
    This is such a GREAT piece! Thank you so much for being so persistent to get the answer! We vacation every summer on a lake in Maine and we come across these crazy eggs everywhere! We have two curious kids so maybe next summer we’ll hatch ours! There are tons of STINKY fresh water snails on our lake that the ducks like to eat, but I haven’t necessarily found any caddisflies. But we will look next summer! Also, we’ll try to get some really good photos, too, and send them to you. Thanks!

  3. I was swimming up in Eagle rive and found tons of these on buoys, I saw that moths too and took some eggs home, me and a friend are going to let them hatch to see if they really are these moths

  4. To Tress and Heather: This question has come back to life in that I just recently got a report from a reliable source that he hatched out some of very similair eggs and the hatchling looks to me to be an aphid nymph, not a caddisfly. I’m trying to track this down. Also, the same researcher found a similar green egg mass that turned out to be snails. I’m still pretty sure that what my readers found last summer was from a caddisfly, but it’s possible there are several very similair egg strings laid by different organisms. Stay tuned.

  5. I found these in North Idaho beginning this July. (Shout out to Hanna!) I’m a graduate student studying periphyton in a lake here and I have artificial growing substrates (elevated styrofoam platforms) submerged at 4m in 6 bays. These eggs are popping up on my substrate eyebolts but I’m guessing they wash off each time I service the substrates weekly. Since these are caddisflies, is it reasonable to find the eggs all the way at 4m? They are attached to the substrate, always around the eyebolt or the vertical suspension rod, not free-floating. I guess I am pulling the substrate to the surface weekly for about 2 minutes and they could be in contact with insects then, but I’ve never seen any bugs flying in my face while I’m messing with them. I’m really curious, so I’ll be asking faculty at the University of Idaho. I have a fellow graduate student who’s studying how the life history and preferential eating habits of caddisflies might change in contaminated waters. I’ll ask her for her opinion.

  6. Hi Randi, I’d have to go back and check my emails, but I vaguely remember that one of the people I spoke with about these said they could be at considerable depth. Can you send me pictures of what you’re finding? Email to tom@askanaturalist.com. Thanks! And let me know what your friend says. If you have the inclination, you could also keep some in a bucket or aquarium and see if they hatch.

  7. I’m going out on Thursday and I’ll bring extra sample bottles to snag some. We’re going to try to hatch them in the lab too so we can look at them with a scope. She’s at a conference this week so I’m going to try and refrigerate them to delay hatching if we can. I’ll send pictures when I get my hands on some. Thanks!

  8. Every year we visit a lake in old forge, ny during July. We find these egg cases hanging from the rope bouts at the swim area. Since we are pretty knowledable about nature we were surprised in not being about to I’d this. Thanks for this post. We can check one more mystery off our list.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

1,204,637 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments