katydid

Cooper’s Hawk or Sharp-Shinned?

The Question: I am sending a picture of what I believe is a Coopers Hawk. We live in Caning, Nova Scotia and I do know it is very rare to have one around here, so if there is any way of letting us know if this is a Cooper’s Hawk or a Sharped-shinned Hawk.

Submitted by: Kelly, Nova Scotia, Canada

The Short Answer: Kelly, the bird in your picture looks like a Sharp-shinned Hawk (Accipiter striatus) to me.

More Information: Your question is a very common one for birders. Cooper’s Hawks (Accipiter cooperii) and Sharp-shinned are closely related and very similar small hawks. They both prey on birds. Their ranges overlap over most of North America.

The Cooper’s Hawk is considerably larger, about the size of a crow, while a Sharp-shinned Hawk is closer to the size of a Blue Jay. But as with most raptors, females are considerably larger than males, and a large female Sharp-shinned Hawk is about the same size as a male Cooper’s Hawk, so unless you have the two species side by side, or the bird is definitely crow-sized, it’s difficult to use size to separate the two. In Kelly’s photograph, there are few size cues, so size isn’t much help here.

One of the most easily noticed differences between the two birds is that the Sharp-shinned Hawk’s tail is squared off when resting, with the outer feathers slightly longer and a small cleft in the middle, and a thin white tip. A Cooper’s Hawk’s tail at rest is rounded, with a larger white tip. It’s on that basis that I feel pretty confident in saying that Kelly has taken an excellent picture of a Sharp-shinned Hawk.

Another tip is that the dark grey coloration on the top of the head of the bird in the photo seems to continue down the back of the neck and connects with the dark coloration of the back. It’s a little hard to tell in the photo, since the bird’s neck is turned away from us, but I’m pretty sure I can see the extension of the color down the back of the neck. This is also indicative of a Sharp-shinned Hawk. A Cooper’s Hawk has more of a “cap.” The dark grey coloration on the top of the head is interrupted by lighter feathers on the back of the neck, so that the bird looks like it has a cap of grey. One way to remember this is that “a Coop has a cap.”

For more detailed descriptions of the two, the Cornell Lab of Ornithology has excellent pages on each species, where you can also hear their different songs:

Sharp-shinned Hawk

Cooper’s Hawk

Added on April 1, 2013 – There is a nice couple of photos at this site that show a Sharp-shinned and a Cooper’s Hawk flying overhead:  http://projectfeederwatch.wordpress.com/2012/05/03/sharp-shinned-hawk-versus-coopers-hawk/

Added on April 15, 2014 – I wrote more about Cooper’s versus Sharp-shinned in a later article:  Cooper’s Hawk or Sharp-shinned – Episodes 2, 3, & 4 (Was it murder?)

Share:
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • RSS
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
Print Friendly Print Friendly

3 Responses

  1. Diane Says:

    I live in st james on Long Island ny this hawk has been in my yard for a few weeks now, visiting my feeder to hunt, I believe it’s a Cooper’s hawk but it is much bigger than a crow

  2. Anne Maher Says:

    I live in Burlington ON. I watched what I think is a Cooper’s hawk devour a small bird. The hawk looked much larger than a crow. It did not have any speckling on its breast.

  3. Tom of AskaNaturalist.com Says:

    The Accipiters, which in North America includes the Coopers hawk, sharp-shinned hawk, and Northern goshawk are known for hunting other birds, but many hawks will kill other birds when given the chance. So without a photo, it would be pretty hard to identify your hawk. You say there was no speckling on the breast. Was the breast white or dark? The goshawk is larger and has a much lighter breast than the Coopers or sharp-shinned, although there is still patterning there. But it might look white from a distance?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags are not allowed.

867,667 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments