katydid

Is this spider venomous?

spider in CalgaryThe Question: This spider crawled out of a vent at my daughter’s home and moved quickly towards the door where she opened it and watched it go outside. My daughter is terrified and wonders if she needs an exterminator? Is this spider venomous? She’s scared to have her baby on the floor. Please help identify this creepy crawler.

Submitted by: Jojo, Calgary, Alberta, Canada

The Short Answer: Unfortunately, this photograph doesn’t show much detail, so we haven’t given Mandy Howe from www.spiders.us much to go on. But her guess is a female giant house spider (Eratigena atrica, previously known as Tegenaria atrica, T. duellica, T. gigantea, and T. saeva – updated in August, 2014), also known as the greater European house spider. Mandy told me:

“Eratigena atrica is present in Albert.  They are very large when full-grown and can run really fast, but are very docile and not considered dangerously venomous to people. They are a European import and are fairly common in and around homes in some of the Canadian provinces as well as the Pacific Northwest of the U.S.

“This kind of spider uses a web to catch its prey (insects and other spiders), so they depend almost entirely on vibrations rather than their poor eyesight. My guess is that the spider was disturbed from its web or was not finding enough food at its current location, so it moved on… these spiders run along the baseboards in homes (sticking to the outsides of rooms, almost like mice do), so her escaping out the door as the reader giant house spideropened it was most likely a coincidence, as the spider was running scared and blind.”

Here’s a better picture of the giant house spider. You can see that it has a very similar shape and posture to your photo.

More Information: The giant house spider is closely related to the more infamous hobo spider (Eratigena agrestis, formerly called Tegenaria agrestis). They and other spiders in the same genus (Eratigena) look very similar. And these spiders certainly are large. A female hobo spider’s body is 11-15 mm (1/2 inch) long. A female giant house spider’s body is 16-18 mm (3/4 inch) long and its leg span can be nearly two inches. Males have smaller bodies, but can have longer legs, with a leg span of nearly three inches! Seeing a spider that big crawling across the floor will get most people’s attention.

Many people think the hobo spider is both aggressive and venomous, and you can find many websites that insist that hobo spiders cause necrotic wounds (wounds that fester and cause tissue death). However, this is all based on a single study that has proven to be unrepeatable. Like the giant house spider and other Eratigena spiders, the hobo spider is highly unlikely to bite and despite its reputation, does not appear to cause serious wounds. A study reported in the Journal of Medical Entomology in 2011 showed that there are no compounds in the bite of a hobo spider that are likely to cause serious wounds. Another theory is that hobo spiders introduce bacteria, but a complete culture of all bacteria found on dozens of hobo spiders showed only common bacteria typically found in the environment. Because there have been rumors that hobo spiders carry MRSA (Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus), an antibiotic-resistant bacteria that is a public health problem, the researchers exposed hobo spiders to MRSA to see if they picked it up from the environment and could therefore introduce it in a bite, but even after exposure, there was no evidence of MRSA on the hobo spiders.

These spiders, both hobo spiders and giant house spiders, are native to Europe, where they have lived in people’s houses for centuries. They were introduced to North America in the 20th century. Oddly enough, in Europe they don’t have a reputation for being aggressive or dangerous, which suggests that their North American reputation could be a myth.  To see a video of a child letting a giant house spider walk all over her hand, go to http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxNpitlKc_s&feature=youtu.be.

People’s fears of spiders are largely unfounded.  Mandy reports that she has handled giant house spiders and many other species for decades without EVER being bitten.  I have picked up and removed hundreds of spiders of all kinds from my house over the years and have never been bitten.  You are far more likely to be bitten by an ant.

So whether the spider in Jojo’s daughter’s house is a giant house spider or a hobo spider, there is little to fear from these spiders. In my opinion, with a baby in the house, I’d be more worried about using pesticides to exterminate spiders than about the spiders.

Sources:

Gaver Wainwright, M, Zack, R S, Foradori, M J, et al. (2011). Misdiagnosis of spider bites: Bacterial associates, mechanical pathogen transfer, and hemolytic potential of venom from the hobo spider, tegenaria agrestis (araneae: Agelenidae). Journal of medical entomology, 48(2), 382-388.

Share:
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • RSS
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
Print Friendly Print Friendly

5 Responses

  1. Lisa Says:

    Great answer! Thanks.

  2. greg Says:

    correct…
    There are hundreds and hundreds of sites stating that tegenaria aggrestis is an agressive spider that wants to bite …. FAR from the truth…
    Agrestis means in the fields and farmland …
    Agelenas spiders are all over south europe in agricultural areas and barns even in my father’s garage on or below olive trees sometimes there are decades nests on sideroads near homes
    Since hobos were transported from europe why there is not even ONE case of necrotic arachnidism in europe or they developed the dermonecrotic agent, sphingomyelinase D, like loxosceles the last century as transported (this can’t simply happened). Tegenaria spiders or better all funnel weaver spiders ALL are quite large. Mosquito window fences and tapes on front door would do the job preventing from entering most of these (not only these at least reduce ) Insecticides are not a solution loose money for no reason …. become hysteric. I am telling you this: if you are on vacations way to your home in the village do a cleaning first (bed, matrices, kitchen floor, sofas attics ….and for god sake dont wear cloths or shoes hanging out for long…not for spiders but for everything simply matters of health.
    remember this big and large spiders are not dangerous.. venomous yes but not a threat at all…in hollywood this could happen…

  3. J Baker Says:

    We also have these spiders in our bedroom this Spring and they ARE biting us! I have put down spider traps and caught 2 but there are more because we are still getting bit (looks like a large mosquito bite and is itchy also). While it’s not toxic that’s for sure it’s not much fun to think a spider is crawling on my bed at night.

  4. Tom of AskaNaturalist.com Says:

    In response to a reader who asserted that she was being bitten by spiders at night, I exchanged a few comments, most of which I have now deleted. But I just want to say that I agree that spiders can bite. It is true, however, that spider experts universally agree that most spiders bite people only in self-defense. I don’t believe there are any spiders known to suck blood, the way mosquitoes or bedbugs or fleas do. So it is unlikely that they would bite regularly. Here is a link to a good site that discusses various possibilities for what might bite a person in bed at night: http://citybugs.tamu.edu/factsheets/biting-stinging/others/ent-3006-2/ and here’s one with pictures that show the typical appearance of different types of bites: http://www.healthline.com/health/bug-bites.

  5. Eva Says:

    To the lady who asserted she had been regularly bitten by spiders: You need to change your bedding, get a new mattress and invest in proper de-fleaing stuff for your pets 😉 Regular bites overnight indicate bedbugs or fleas. While fleas don’t live on humans, they most definitely can bite and if you are even slightly allergic to their saliva, bites can quickly become extremely itchy and swollen, like giant mosquito bites. I’m alergic myself and I foster animals, so I’ve got scars around my ankles from flea bites… While I know it’s uncomfortable and even painful, it’s not caused by spiders.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags are not allowed.

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled, so your comment may not show up immediately. Also, it's possible for your comment to be blocked incorrectly by the spam blocker. If you don't see your comment within a day or so, please use the Contact link in the menu above.

863,866 Spambots Blocked by Simple Comments